[MMM-Buttons] Connect multiple buttons to send configurable notifications

istepgueu

@Mar i have same problem. I run my little script button.py before start MM and its solve the problem

Mar

@istepgueu Ive taken your button.py program and modified it for me two buttons 5/6. And while the program reads my button presses perfectly, MM-Buttons doesnt at all. I pretty much have to double click each time to make a button register. It switches my profiles just fine … but just takes lots of clicks to register.

import RPi.GPIO as GPIO
import time

GPIO.setmode(GPIO.BCM)
GPIO.setup(5, GPIO.IN, pull_up_down=GPIO.PUD_UP)
GPIO.setup(6, GPIO.IN, pull_up_down=GPIO.PUD_UP)

tries = 0

while (tries < 200000):
    if GPIO.input(6):
        print("Open 6")
    else:
        print("Close 6")
    if GPIO.input(5):
        print("Open 5")
    else:
        print ("Close 5")
    time.sleep(0.5)
    tries = tries + 1

Mar

@istepgueu Will take a look through this now, but i already have a 1k resistor between pins 5/6 and the respective button. Hopefully something else comes up here.

Yes my problem seems a bit opposite of what was posted in your link. I dont have any erroneous button presses, it just takes a few clicks until MMM-Buttons registers the click. You button.py registers every click instantly. So must be something in the buttons code?

Jopyth

@Mar @istepgueu The library (onoff) I am currently using does not directly allow configuring pull up and pull down resistors, and I was not able to make it consistently work (see Readme).

Therefore I myself made use of the “right” pins for my setup, as the readme says:

The defaults can be seen in Table 6-31 on pages 102 and 103 of the BCM2835 ARM Peripherals documentation.

There I simply used buttons with the correct default pull-up/pull-down resistor configuration (second column of that table), and I wanted a few pins close together on the board, so I chose GPIO 22,23,24 and 25 (connected 4 buttons), since they all have the default of a low input.

Mar

@Jopyth Thanks for the response, and that seems to make complete sense. I missed that part in the documentation.

Though upon trying PINS 22/23 i am still getting the same result. The button.py program detects each individual click properly, but in the MM I have to double (sometimes triple) click the button so that it registers. I can see it registers as it shows up in the pm2 logs and my profile changes.

Im not sure if its an issue with the buttons as they are a standard 4 pin button and the test script works fine with them?

Jopyth

@Mar Well its not, as if it were documented anywhere in my readme. :( Should probably add this somewhere.

How long are you pressing the button? For a very short time? Note, that if the press is longer than 500ms it will not be registered as a (short) press (it is the maxShortPressTime and can be configured).

If this is not the case, I am sorry, but I have no real idea how to fix it, without having the same situation on my Pi.

Mar

@Jopyth I thought this also, and set the short time from 0-1000ms and still will only register the second of a double click.

Its very consistent though, i can get it to work 100% of the time with a double click like opening a folder on the computer. one click doesnt do anything, and I don’t believe the longPress worked at all (But i wasnt using it so not that bothered with it).

Maybe its just the buttons…i just dont have anything else around that i could use to test as a button.

Mar

@Jopyth Just tested with buttons ripped out from an old monitor and same issue, needed to double click. I suppose i will slowly go through the code and try break it down and see. any advice on which functions to start with?

Mar

@Jopyth Fixed!! I switched the 1 and the 0 in the watchHandler function of node_helper.js and solved the issue. Must have been backwards with how the button was being interpreted vs set up?

Put the 0 first, then 1.

Now the double click makes sense, the time between the clicks seems to have been what was counted as a valid min press time.

Mar

@Jopyth Anyway to use one button to switch between profiles? Trying to use profile switches classes and creating the same button on different profiles (classes) but it always runs both buttons so take me back to the default page.