MMM-Carousel; Two of the Same Module?

dathbe

Is there any functional difference between MMM-Pages and MMM-Carousel? I’m using Carousel, but just stumbled across Pages and am wondering if the grass is greener on that side…

sdetweil

@dathbe roughly the same . the buttons are a separate modules

and because it uses classes , the duplicates are easier

sdetweil

@dathbe I like the flexibility of pages, you can use the module classes: property
outside the module config for multiple instances of the same module
(and use the same value in custom.css selectors)

I updated the doc on how to use a fixed page name structure

“page1”,
“page2”,
“page3”

and use those values in the classes: of the modules you want to group together

I always had trouble remembering, is THIS module on page 2 or 3?
have to go back and look at the config(using module names)
and then back down, lose my place, repeat

now the module itself lists the page its on…
no id’s, no weird settings,

my forks of pages, Carousel and ModulesGroupsRotation all provide a property to have different display times for different pages.

and the page name can be anything

Mom, Dad, joe, finance, power mgmt, … so it helps you organize the data (me at least)

dathbe

@sdetweil I like the idea of scheduling display times for pages.

Most of the rest of this it seems like I can do with Carousel–including giving the pages sensible names, and labeling certain modules to correspond with those pages–if, perhaps, in a bit more clunky way.

sdetweil

@dathbe i added display times to carousel too

sdetweil

@dathbe my MMM-Config module doesn’t understand the carouselId inside the module config. . just cause you CAN code it doesn’t mean you should