Microwave/doppler motion detection -- anyone got it to work?

[randomnoise]

@invisible.inq OK, sounds like you confirmed it does work then (sometimes certain devices need a resistor wired in series with either gnd or the input pin so just thought it may have been a factor).

Only other obvious thing I can think of is to confirm pin no in your mmm-pir-sensor config is correct… Your script uses bcm numbering pin 17 so configuration needs 17 as well.

[goprojojo]

Were you able to resolve the issue? I’m looking for a microwave sensor too. What sensor do you have?

[invisible.inq]

@goprojojo Short answer is no.

I’ve tried the HFS-DC06, XYC-WB-D0, and the RCWL-0516 chips. I’ve tried the MMM-PIR-Sensor and PIR-Sensor modules.

Some observations:

• Some of these chips are junk. I bought a pack of 4 RCWL-0516 chips from amazon, and only 2 of them worked. The HFS-DC06 chip has two adjustable settings, but I’m not convinced they work correctly
  -MMM-PIR-Sensor (paviro) seems to be less of a draw on resources. PIR-Sensor (cowboysdude) seemed simpler to me, but never worked quite as well
• I do first test with the python code above, to verify that I’m getting signal. That’s a simple way to test the chips. But for whatever reason, that hasn’t translated into signal that either of the modules would act on correctly
• At one point, I thought I had it working, but I was getting a lot of false-positives. Unfortunately I didn’t have any capacitors laying around to build a pi-filter. When I got them ordered, I couldn’t recreate the false positives. Pi-filter: schematic from this [thread]
  (https://github.com/jdesbonnet/RCWL-0516/issues/2). It’s simple enough to assemble on a breadboard.
• At the same time, I also grabbed some ferrite beads based on this [thread].
  (https://helentronica.com/2016/01/11/magic-mirror-with-motion-detector/). I figure that’s a good precaution.
• Depending on how old your monitor is, shutting off and turning on the HDMI outlet may be more trouble than it’s worth. If you just want the screen to go blank, this has worked ok for me when I manually activate it:
  xset -display :0 s blank && xset -display :0 dpms force off

I plan to spend some more time on it this weekend. I’ll let you know if I get it working.

[j.e.f.f]

I’m going to guess you issue isn’t the sensor, but instead how your monitor reacts to the vcgencmd command. Had you tried installing LibCEC and sending direct CEC power commands?

[invisible.inq]

@j.e.f.f I don’t think so, but i could be off. As a second datapoint, I’m having the module run a shell script on status change, which first writes the current time to a log file, before then triggering xset or vcgencmd. I don’t think it’s vcgencmd that is causing me issue.