Automatic checking of all MagicMirror² modules

sdetweil

I’m also ok with this style list becoming the current. but I think the order of task needs to change

show how to resolve the integrity problem, without constant intervention
show the automation
then move to org
then redirect links, and seo
and
show how we migrate the list as new requirements come along. is it you that becomes the maintainer?

mumblebaj

@KristjanESPERANTO My 20pence/cents worth, I vote to make this the official page. We need to move with the times and the old page is outdated.

KristjanESPERANTO

@sdetweil said:

show how to resolve the integrity problem, without constant intervention

With “integrity problem” you are talking about how to add new modules to the list?

I’m also fine with your order of tasks :slightly_smiling_face:

is it you that becomes the maintainer?

A maintainer of this project, yes. But as I understand it, we can assign different teams with different roles for each project. So I don’t automatically have to become a maintainer of the core.

sdetweil

@KristjanESPERANTO integrity.

you said user error or vandal mess up the data

currently we don’t have different roles.

but that wasn’t my point.

I have enough on my plate and wouldn’t be able to maintain this

BKeyport

@mumblebaj Old page may be outdated, but at least it’s sorted much better, and compact. New and flashy does not make a successful page sometimes.

We need to keep the compactness of the old way, somehow, and not bury good modules under bad ones - this is the main problem I see with this site.

I can’t hit my browser’s text search and look for calendar for example. I get MMM-CX2 and MMM-CX before I even come close to the current MMM-CX3, and totally miss my mini calendar module.

mumblebaj

@BKeyport As an IT person I would say we need to move with the times. Being stuck in the old is never good. Have you tagged your modules as per the stats gathered on it?

BKeyport

@mumblebaj 90% of the modules in the system are outdated and would never be tagged, so…

mumblebaj

@BKeyport Gives users an indication that they are outdated and may not be supported. My point is being stuck in the past is never a good idea unless you want your project to “die”

sdetweil

@mumblebaj lots of useful modules haven’t been updated. pages for example…

so old is not bad necessarily

MMRIZE

I don’t care if it is not updated or not as long as it works.
However, we can call some unmaintained-anymore modules legacy. Maybe a tag legacy to some old modules be a good way to distinguish. By contrast, the other side might be modern.

If possible, I wish for more features/rules for common "modern" modules. These could help automate the management of modules.

Installer command/script/instruction
Some modules may need additional manual pre-requisition or dependency jobs (e.g. getting auth), but most of the modules would be possible to prepare simple scripts for installation. (in package.json and specific installer folder). If so, we can provide an auto-install/update feature to MM.
Basic default configuration example file.
If possible, a default config example would be a help for the newbie, and with that content, auto-configuration would be possible in the installation stage.
Of course, there might be private-information or API-Key issues…
Using .env to store private/secure information. (Or private.json something…)
To separate normal configuration from sophisticated private data (e.g., API Key, Account, password, etc.) , using .env may be the option. It could be composed through an installation script if needed.

I wish we could have something like a plugins market or bundle store of other applications.