[MMM-JaST] Just another Stock Ticker (new: version 2.x)

Jalibu

@Overbid4225 please check your logs: API request for BOQ.AS failed: Quote not found for ticker symbol: BOQ.AS
This message does not come from the MMM-Jast module, but from the Yahoo Finance library. Apparently a required value is not available for this symbol.
Since MMM-Jast depends on the results of the Yahoo Finance Library, unfortunately I can’t help you here either.

Overbid4225

@Jalibu I see, thanks for the reply. Strange on Yahoo’s part to resolve BOQ.AS on their website or any other asx for that matter but not allow on API. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/BOQ.AX?p=BOQ.AX&.tsrc=fin-srch

Jalibu

@Overbid4225 yap, that‘s strange. The Yahoo Finanance library is unofficial and does not use a public API. Instead it just parses the Yahoo Website ;-)

Dracarys

@Jalibu Hi, for me the module just stopped working since yesterday. It only says ‘loading’. Restartig the mirror doesnt Help. Before that it worked flawlessly for months. Is it Just me or does anyone else have this problem too?

Jalibu

@Dracarys It still works for me without any problems.
Do you get any logs?

Dracarys

I will post it as soon as i have the time :)

EDIT:

[30.06.2022 01:07.44.449] [ERROR] There was an error requesting the API. Failed Yahoo Schema validation

Jalibu

@Dracarys
That’s strange. Can you sort out which symbol causes this error?

If it makes you happy, right now it’s better to see an error message on the mirror than to be shown the current stock performance.

Dracarys

i just got rid of all smybols and used BMW.DE Its still the same unfortunately. I even updated on the last version of jast but that also didnt help.

Jalibu

@Dracarys can you please create an issue on Github? https://github.com/jalibu/MMM-Jast/issues

Dracarys

@Jalibu Since my magicmirror is running since a few years without updates/upgrades i updated everything (Rpi, MagicMirror, Node, Jast etc…). Now the module works again :)

MartinLoidolt

@Dracarys I updated nearly everything I could find.
Could you tell me what you exactly updated?

MartinLoidolt

@Dracarys Nevermind i fixed it

spitzlbergerj

Hi Jan @Jalibu

Thank you very much for this great Stocks module. The beer is already on the way. It’s best to choose Bavarian! :-)

I have contributed a bit to the MMM-AVStock module (https://github.com/lavolp3/MMM-AVStock). Unfortunately TypeScript is not one of my languages, so I can help less there.

You have already recorded the number of existing stocks. If we could add the purchase price, then a display like in MMM-AVStock would be possible. In addition to the current prices and their development, the own portfolio is then also shown in the development.

Bild Text

If I can help you in any way, please let me know.

And another suggestion. I would like to have the representation like the horizontal ticker, only without ticker. So the display would be shown horizontally. But there is nothing running through.

Thanks again

Many greetings

Sepp

MZ-BER

Hi @Jalibu - first, thanks for the great module and all the effort to help.

I was playing with the Depot feature and added all the quantities. It functions correctly, providing me with the current value based on the current market price of the stock. Now I’m wondering if is there a way to calculate the price gain since purchase, similar to the example provided?

Is it possible to add the purchase price next to the quantity, so that the price gain or loss can be automatically calculated based on the current price?

Best regards from Berlin

-Manuel

Jalibu

@MZ-BER thanks for your feedback. Also @spitzlbergerj asked for such a feature.
Technically, the implementation (and calculation) should be very easy. The tricky part is to get this fitting into the different display modes/styles (e.g. horizontal, vertical scrolling). The horizontal scrolling values for example are hard to understand without any caption for what they stand for.
In a table view like your’s, that’s easy and I’ve been thinking for a long time to introduce an additional table mode (like MMM-AVStock for example). The reason why I haven’t so far implemented this is, that I want to avoid that some features are only visible in a subset of modes/styles.

But since several people have already expressed their wish and one shouldn’t hold back improvements because one could theoretically make it even better, I’ll try to implement that soon.

spitzlbergerj

Hi @Jalibu
I don’t think it’s really a problem to understand the values even without appropriate tags. It’s not like there are hundreds of unknown and untrained people looking at such a MagicMirror. It is rather family or smaller teams that look at the displays. And those who are interested in shares quickly know what means what. That’s how it is in my proposal. On MagicMirror, the color of the values is usually enough for me to decide whether to trade. Everything else happens on the trading platform.

I use many models in different views on my different MagicMirrors. With almost all modules, the different views also offer different functionalities. That’s kind of the point of a view - a different look at the same raw data. so I wouldn’t have a problem with that.

And as already said, I would like to help. Unfortunately I lack the knowledge of the programming language used and the appropriate development environment.

Many greetings and happy coding
Sepp

Jalibu

@spitzlbergerj @MZ-BER
I added some options to calculate the stock’s and the portfolio’s performance based on the purchase price.
You can test it in the module’s development branch: https://github.com/jalibu/MMM-Jast/tree/development

It currently looks like this which is not very pretty, imho. Please share your feedback and thoughts for further improvement.

PS: Inspired by this, I thought of a new display mode with a table with sticky header and alternating body in the future.

Jalibu

@spitzlbergerj @MZ-BER
I introduced a first draft for a table view. You can select a “page size” for stock rotation.

Please share your feedback.

MZ-BER

@Jalibu - fantastic Job! I just pulled the dev version and added the purchasePrice next to the quantity. The calculation is functioning properly. There is a slight discrepancy in the total amount, which is likely due to the exchange where I obtained my information. (The screenshot is from Parquet and they are utilizing Xetra as their exchange.

Overall the first iteration is really good.

Here some feedback (will share more as soon as I have time):

Some of my stocks/ETFs have three decimal places for the prices (Column Kursgewinn)
By adding more options like value increase % or total ect. new columns with header should be created. Otherwise it is confusing to understand where the number refers to.
Kursgewinn could be colored with green or red

spitzlbergerj

@Jalibu
Thank you very much for these variants. I’m on the road and unfortunately won’t be able to test live in the next days.

I don’t really have much room for the stocks on the mirror unfortunately. Three lines at the bottom is all I can use. So the Views I posted initially was my very favorite.

Suggestion 1: expand the ticker format to show each stock in two lines

Share 1                                 Share 2                               Share 3 ... 
current price  current performace       current price current performace      current price current performace ...
purchase price purchase performace      purchase price purchase performace    purchase price purchase performace ...

Suggestion 2: Ticker to switch off

Suggestion 3: gladly also your new ticker view, then however options whether the respective values are to be faded in.

regards
Josef