No Country (Bluetooth) For Old Men

[A Former User]

@Mykle1

What is your problem? You cannnot send audio to your bt speaker?
if you are not using any other output device, set off them.
Or, when you play some sounds, see the playback tab. You can change the output device by manual(only in playing)

And… do you have trouble with auto pairing? Finally I add some script( echo -e "connect 00:00:00:00:00:00\nquit" | bluetoothctl) on bootup(frankly on mm startup)

Have a good luck

[Kimzer]

How would the sound be with that? I tried with audio jack and it sounded terrible.

[A Former User]

@Kimzer bluetooth with external power would sound clear surely. I moved to bt because of noise of soundjack and usb connected speaker

[CaptCutter]

Thank you @Sean !! I’ve been trying like Mykle1 but also with no luck…perhaps this will work!

[d3r]

@Mykle1
What’s your exact issue? Does it work then gets disconnected?
I struggled a lot with bluetooth audio on the pi3. In the end I had to disable the onboard chip and use a usb dongle.
Edit:
From your screenshots it looks like it’s connected. Apprently the correct way to connect the speaker once you device is paired is to right click on the speaker icon on the right then select your bluetooth speaker(It should be listed there).

[Mykle1]

This post is deleted!

[Mykle1]

Unfortunately, my last post was only partially displayed. I described in detail what was happening. I don’t have the will to retype it.

In short, I got an mp3 to play through the BT speaker but it stopped when the Pi’s BT failed about 3/4 of the way through the song. Unable to reconnect the speaker. Rebooting. I’ll keep you both posted. Thank you both, Sean and d3r

EDIT 5 minutes later

Rebooted, in the RUN CMD window I type start-pulseaudio-x11 because I don’t have it in startup yet. Pulseaudio enables the Volume Control window. Bluetooth connects to the speaker nicely when I right click on the speaker in the Bluetooth Device window. I played the mp3 file again using mpg123. The song started playing immediately but only played 10 seconds before BT failed again. Here is a picture of the Bluetooth Devices window showing the speaker in its frozen state. The activity indicator is frozen as you see it in the picture.

EDIT - 15 minutes later

I’ve determined that BOTH pulseaudio and BT are failing. I don’t know if one is causing the other to fail but both are definitely failing. The Bluetooth Devices window is easy to see because the activity indicator freezes. I know now that pulseaudio fails because the speaker disappears from the Output Devices of Volume Control which is pulseaudio.

Reboot #4! I really hope one of you can give me some advice. Thanks again!

[Mykle1]

@d3r
@Sean
With each successive reboot the failure seemed to come sooner and sooner, wherein the crash came before I even got to play the sound file. I’ve had it for the night. Maybe I’ll run into you guys tomorrow.

Peace!

[d3r]

@Mykle1 If you’re on jessie (with pixel), keep reading this post. I think you mentioned you have blueman installed. You don’t need blueman anymore. I would recommend getting rid of it. Pixel comes with pi-bluetooth which is supposed to make things easier for audio. Notice how you have 2 bluetooth icons in your taskbar? They could be conflicting.
Please also see this link https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/another-update-raspbian/ for how to connect the speaker. It should work.
Of course do back up your card in case something goes wrong.

Raspbian Stretch also changed some stuff about bluetooth, maybe take a look at that if you have a spare sd card lying around. I personally haven’t tried it yet.
https://www.raspberrypi.org/blog/raspbian-stretch/

This is how mine looks

[Mykle1]

@d3r said in No Country (Bluetooth) For Old Men:

You don’t need blueman anymore

I really can’t wait to try your suggestions. I have other household matters to take care of first (says the wife). I will report back to you later when I’ve tried. Many thanks for your input and advice!

[Mykle1]

Finally finished working my butt off today. Now, I take a stab at your suggestions. Wish me luck!

[Mykle1]

@d3r said in No Country (Bluetooth) For Old Men:

You don’t need blueman anymore.

Just to clarify, pulseaudio stays? I’ve removed Blueman

[d3r]

@Mykle1
Ya. Pulseaudio stays.

[Mykle1]

@d3r said in No Country (Bluetooth) For Old Men:

Ya. Pulseaudio stays.

Ok, I thought so. I’ll have an update in a little while

[d3r]

@Mykle1 you might have to be remove (forget) the speaker on your pi bluetooth and restart the pi again once you remove blueman.

[Mykle1]

@d3r said in No Country (Bluetooth) For Old Men:

you might have to be remove (forget) the speaker on your pi bluetooth and restart the pi again once you remove blueman.

I haven’t tried that. Pairing doesn’t seem to be my problem. The speaker pairs automatically.

Let me explain my sequence and result

The first thing I have to do is RUN start-pulseaudio-x11 because I don’t have it in startup yet. This enables the Volume Control where I clearly see the speaker connected.

Click on the Bluetooth icon and again, I see the speaker is paired

Right click the Volume icon and I see the speaker but it is not chosen yet.

Following the directions of the link you gave, I click on HMDX in the drop down menu of the volume icon, but this is the result

My pulseaudio is up to date.

I’ll remove the speaker and add it again if you think that will help

[Mykle1]

@Mykle1 said in No Country (Bluetooth) For Old Men:

I’ll remove the speaker and add it again

As it turns out, that was a bad idea. Now the Pi does not see the speaker.

[d3r]

@Mykle1 Sorry to hear it’s not working.
When you reboot try it without running the start-pulseaudio-x11 command. If that doesn’t work, I’m lost.
Iirc, when I set mine up, I paired the speaker, then did the right click on the speaker icon to change it to the bluetooth speaker.

[Mykle1]

@d3r

I can’t try anything right now. The Pi doesn’t see the speaker since I removed it. I can’t add it because it doesn’t appear in the Add Device window

[d3r]

@Mykle1 try the command line instead of the gui to pair your speaker.
Run bluetoothctl in terminal.
Then type:
power on
Default-agent
Agent on
Scan on
then see if bluetoothct sees the speaker.