Further module categories...

cowboysdude

With all the new modules coming out it’s hard to tell where to put what at times…

My suggestion would be to add sub-categories… I know it’s a lot of work [I run a forum] but at times to help people figure out where to post them correctly… Just an idea.

Mykle1

@cowboysdude Dude, what forum do you run?

yawns

@cowboysdude

Could you name some additional categories? I would avoid adding sub-categories, because users would have to work their way down the “tree”.

Jopyth

For reference: I started a similar discussion a few months ago here. Except for the weather/environment category, all have been created.

@cowboysdude What changes do you suggest?

I think Utilities is the category that needs “refurbishing” the most. It is basically the category all modules go in, which have no other fitting category and we probably need one like it, but maybe we can try to split it up. My suggestion from back then still stands, we could introduce a Weather/Environment category. Are there enough module to justify a Smart Home, a Sensors (GPIO integrations), a Voice Recognition or a Configuration category?

Also I agree with @yawns, new and changed categories would maybe be better than splitting some categories another time.

yawns

@Jopyth said in Further module categories...:

I think Utilities is the category that needs “refurbishing” the most. It is basically the category all modules go in, which have no other fitting category and we probably need one like it, but maybe we can try to split it up.

Totally agree!

possible categories

Smart Home

Sensors* (GPIO integrations)

Voice Recognition

Configuration

Not sure what about the configuration category (I guess you intend sharing configurations?), but I support the other suggestions.

cowboysdude

My suggestion is putting in for instance under each Topic and separate each module into subcategories…

The reason I say that is because when I was posting modules I had a difficult time trying to figure out where to put a couple of them… not sure where they fit.

A great example is Utilities… looks like modules where dumped there because people couldn’t figure out where to put them.

You have Voice control, thermostat control, network scanner, etc…

Voice control is a mirror util
Thermostat is a home util
Network scanner is a mirror util…

Things like that

Jopyth

@yawns Actually I was talking about modules for configuration purposes (Mobile App, Admin Interface, …), but maybe they should just belong to the general System category.

yawns

@Jopyth
Ah ok, that makes alot more sense to me

cowboysdude

Sorry @Jopyth I was thinking of further defining categories…

Jopyth

@cowboysdude So you would go with sub-categories, rather than defining new base categories? It not completely clear to me though, which categories you would split, and which subcategories you suggest? Or do you just want example below the categories, so it is easier to see where a module should go?

Also, maybe the future should go more into the direction of @MichMich’s module beta for showcasing modules.